Posted: February 3, 2009

Reducing nanotechnology liability exposure when risks are unknown

(Nanowerk News) In their Insighter article on the Food and Drug Law Institute's website (, Ash, Klapper and Wood, part of a team of more than two dozen attorneys involved in nanotechnology issues at the law firm of Reed Smith, note that while there has not been a single lawsuit filed where someone claimed injury because they were exposed to engineered nanomaterials, many scientists are raising questions regarding the manufacturing of nanomaterials and its effects on workforces, researchers and consumers.
Please also see our Nanowerk Spotlight "Nanotechnology litigation: Winning the war before it starts" by Skip Lockard on this issue.
They write that, "for example, the plaintiffs’ bar likely took note of a recent study showing that certain types of carbon nanotubes, graphite-based structures commonly used in nanotechnology applications, both resemble and behave like asbestos fibers. Because they are as light as plastic and stronger than steel, carbon nanotubes will likely see use in a variety of new applications, including medical nanodevices.
"Based on toxicity studies, scientists found that inhaling long, thin multi-walled carbon nanotubes had the potential to cause lung disorders similar to those caused by exposure to asbestos. While this conclusion is alarming, the authors of this study were quick to point out that additional research will be required to fully answer whether carbon nanotubes truly are pathogenetic in humans. Regardless, the “carbon nanotube” story is an important one for companies to stay on top of and monitor. And so too are developments in the story about the toxicological properties of nanosized silver, a substance used in some medical devices to prevent infections.
"The plaintiffs’ bar is also monitoring activities at FDA. In May 2006, a coalition of environmental NGOs filed a petition asking the FDA to, among other things, force manufacturers of sunscreens that use nanoparticles to cease production and to recall their products. The petition discusses at length the possibly increased toxic properties of nanomaterials, citing to various scholarly articles and reports. FDA has not formally responded to this particular petition, but has held several public meetings on nanotechnology risks during the past three years.
"Whether the studies on carbon nanotubes or the public petitions simply mark the beginning of private lawsuits is unknown. Certainly if the science on nanomaterials more conclusively raises human health concerns, the risk of litigation increases dramatically. Because there are many unanswered questions regarding risk, it is essential that companies follow the principles of good product stewardship activities and good risk management strategies in the design and manufacturing of products made with engineered nanomaterials. Core questions that affect whether a company has followed such principles include:
  • Has the company designed the product with safety in mind?
  • Has the company educated its workers and consumers about known exposure risks?
  • Has the company tracked what scientists, regulators and other members of industry are saying and doing about the product’s risk and ways to reduce that risk?
  • Has the company itself evaluated, or collaborated with others to evaluate, risks that are still unknown?
  • Are the company’s public pronouncements about the risks associated with its products consistent with its own internal evaluations and assessments of its products?
  • Has the company taken affirmative steps to implement recommended controls to reduce exposures?
  • Has the company taken steps to monitor the health of its workforce and its consumers that are exposed to its product?
  • "
    These issue will be thoroughly explored at FDLI's 2nd Annual Conference on Nanotechnology Law, Regulation and Policy, February 18-19, 2009, in Washington, D.C., and discussed in a book to be published by FDLI February 17, Nanotechnology & FDA-Regulated Products: The Essential Guide. At the conference, six top officials of the Food and Drug Administration will answer questions about how the new Administration intends to regulate nanotechnology products.
    Source: FDLI
    Subscribe to a free copy of one of our daily
    Nanowerk Newsletter Email Digests
    with a compilation of all of the day's news.
    These articles might interest you as well: